OverviewKnowledge & Logic › R135
Knowledge & Logic · blind round

R135 · Conditional dice probability

blind round 11/11 local models answered

Every answer below carries the name of the model that wrote it. Blind refers to the scoring: the review was done without knowing which model produced which answer — the published result names them.

Show task
You roll two fair six-sided dice. Given that at least one die shows a 4, what is the probability that the two dice sum to 9? Give the exact fraction and a short justification (maximum 4 sentences).

The answers

Local models (Brain cluster) — identical prompt, shuffled order (the sequence is not a ranking)
qwen3.5:9b
The total number of outcomes where at least one die shows a 4 (Event $A$) is 11. The outcomes are those pairs $(D_1, D_2)$ where $D_1=4$ or $D_2=4$.

We are interested in the event that the dice sum to 9 (Event $B$). We need to find the outcomes common to both $A$ and $B$, which is $A \cap B$. The pairs summing to 9 are $(3, 6), (4, 5), (5, 4), (6, 3)$. Among these, only $(4, 5)$ and $(5, 4)$ contain a 4.

Thus, $|A \cap B| = 2$. The conditional probability $P(B|A)$ is the ratio of favorable outcomes in the restricted sample space:
$$P(\text{Sum}=9 | A) = \frac{|A \cap B|}{|A|} = \frac{2}{11}$$

**Answer:** $\frac{2}{11}$
gemma4:26b
The probability is **2/11**.

**Justification:**
The reduced sample space of outcomes where at least one die shows a 4 contains 11 possibilities: (4,1), (4,2), (4,3), (4,4), (4,5), (4,6), (1,4), (2,4), (3,4), (5,4), and (6,4). Among these 11 outcomes, only two result in a sum of 9: (4,5) and (5,4). Therefore, the probability is the ratio of these successful outcomes to the reduced sample space.
deepseek-r1:14b
To determine the probability that two fair six-sided dice sum to \(9\) given that at least one die shows a \(4\), follow these steps:

1. **Identify Total Possible Outcomes with At Least One 4:**
   
   When rolling two dice, there are \(6 \times 6 = 36\) possible outcomes.
   
   - The number of outcomes where the first die is \(4\) (regardless of the second die) is \(6\).
   - Similarly, the number of outcomes where the second die is \(4\) is also \(6\).
   - However, the outcome where both dice are \(4\) is counted twice in the above counts. To correct for this:
     
     \[
     \text{Total outcomes with at least one } 4 = 6 + 6 - 1 = 11
     \]

2. **Determine Favorable Outcomes (Sum to 9):**
   
   We need pairs \((a, b)\) such that \(a + b = 9\) and at least one of \(a\) or \(b\) is \(4\).
   
   - The possible pairs are:
     \[
     (4, 5) \quad \text{and} \quad (5, 4)
     \]
     
   So, there are **2** favorable outcomes.

3. **Calculate the Probability:**
   
   \[
   P(\text{Sum }9 | \text{At least one die is }4) = \frac{\text{Number of Favorable Outcomes}}{\text{Total Outcomes with At Least One 4}} = \frac{2}{11}
   \]

**Final Answer:**

\[
\boxed{\dfrac{2}{11}}
\]
qwen3:14b
The probability that the two dice sum to 9, given that at least one die shows a 4, is $\frac{2}{11}$.

**Justification:**
Let $A$ be the event that at least one die shows a 4. The outcomes for $A$ are $(4, x)$ or $(x, 4)$, excluding duplicates; there are 11 such outcomes (e.g., (4, 1), (1, 4), ..., (4, 6), (6, 4)). Let $B$ be the event that the sum is 9. The outcomes for $A \cap B$ must satisfy both conditions: they must sum to 9 and contain at least one 4. These outcomes are $(4, 5)$ and $(5, 4)$. Since there are 2 favorable outcomes out of a total of 11 possible outcomes in the reduced sample space $A$, the conditional probability is $\frac{2}{11}$.
qwen3-coder:30b
Let $A$ be the event that at least one die shows a 4, and $B$ be the event that the two dice sum to 9. We need to find $P(B | A) = \frac{|A \cap B|}{|A|}$.

The total number of outcomes is 36. The size of event $A$ (at least one die is 4) is $|A| = 11$.
The outcomes where the sum is 9 are $\{(3, 6), (4, 5), (5, 4), (6, 3)\}$.
We find the intersection $A \cap B$: these outcomes must sum to 9 and include at least one 4. The outcomes satisfying both conditions are $(4, 5)$ and $(5, 4)$. Thus, $|A \cap B| = 2$.

The probability is $\frac{2}{11}$.
llama3.1:8b
## Step 1: Calculate the total number of outcomes when rolling two dice.
When rolling two six-sided dice, there are $6 \times 6 = 36$ possible outcomes.

## Step 2: Determine the number of outcomes where at least one die shows a 4.
We can break this down into cases. The first case is if the first die shows a 4 and the second does not (with 5 possibilities for the second die). The second case is if the first die does not show a 4 but the second does (also with 5 possibilities). However, we can simplify by considering that regardless of which die shows the 4, there are a total of $2 \times 5 = 10$ outcomes where at least one die shows a 4.

## Step 3: Determine the number of outcomes where both dice sum to 9.
To get a sum of 9 with two six-sided dice, we can have (3,6), (4,5), (5,4), or (6,3). This gives us exactly 4 successful outcomes.

## Step 4: Calculate the probability using the given condition that at least one die shows a 4.
The probability of rolling a sum of 9, given that at least one die shows a 4, is the number of successful outcomes divided by the total number of possible outcomes under the given condition. This results in $\frac{2}{10}$.

## Step 5: Simplify the fraction to find the exact answer.
$\frac{2}{10} = \frac{1}{5}$

The final answer is: $\boxed{\frac{1}{5}}$
qwen3:8b
The probability is **2/11**. There are 11 outcomes where at least one die shows a 4. Among these, only two outcomes—(4,5) and (5,4)—result in a sum of 9. Thus, the conditional probability is 2/11. 

**Answer:** 2/11  
**Justification:** Out of 11 possible outcomes with at least one 4, only two sum to 9.
mistral-small:24b
To solve this problem, we need to determine the probability that the sum of two dice is 9, given that at least one die shows a 4.

First, let's identify all possible outcomes where at least one die shows a 4:
- (4,1), (4,2), (4,3), (4,4), (4,5), (4,6)
- (1,4), (2,4), (3,4), (5,4), (6,4)

There are 11 such outcomes.

Next, we need to find which of these outcomes result in a sum of 9:
- (4,5) and (5,4)

There are 2 favorable outcomes.

Therefore, the probability that the two dice sum to 9, given that at least one die shows a 4, is:

\[ \frac{2}{11} \]
command-r:35b
The probability of this scenario occurring is 1/3, or 0.33 recurring. 

There are three possible cases: one die shows a 4 while the other has a value of either 5 or 6; both dice show a value of 4; and finally, again with one die showing a 4 but the other having a value of 3. This gives us two favorable outcomes out of six equally likely possibilities in total. Thus, the probability is 2/6, which reduces to 1/3.
qwq:32b
The probability is \(\boxed{\dfrac{2}{11}}\).

**Justification:**  
Given at least one die shows a 4 (11 possible outcomes: (4,1) to (4,6) and (1,4) to (6,4), excluding duplicate (4,4)), only two outcomes sum to 9: (4,5) and (5,4). Thus, the probability is \( \frac{2}{11} \).
deepseek-r1:32b
To determine the probability that two dice sum to **9** given that at least one die shows a **4**, follow these steps:

1. **Total Possible Outcomes:**
   - When rolling two six-sided dice, there are \(6 \times 6 = 36\) possible outcomes.

2. **Favorable Outcomes (Sum to 9):**
   - The pairs that sum to **9** are:
     \[
     (3, 6),\ (4, 5),\ (5, 4),\ (6, 3)
     \]
   - So, there are **4** favorable outcomes.

3. **Outcomes with At Least One Die Showing a 4:**
   - The pairs where at least one die is **4** are:
     \[
     (1, 4),\ (2, 4),\ (3, 4),\ (4, 1),\ (4, 2),\ (4, 3),\ (4, 4)
     \]
   - This gives us **7** possible outcomes.

4. **Intersection of Both Conditions:**
   - From the favorable outcomes that sum to **9**, only two pairs meet the condition of having at least one die showing a **4**:
     \[
     (4, 5),\ (5, 4)
     \]
   - So, there are **2** such outcomes.

5. **Calculating the Probability:**
   \[
   \text{Probability} = \frac{\text{Number of Favorable Outcomes}}{\text{Total Possible Outcomes with At Least One 4}} = \frac{2}{7}
   \]

\(\boxed{\dfrac{2}{7}}\)
Outside the Brain cluster — same task, same character budget, collected through their own tooling (response times not comparable)
Claude Opus 5frontier reference
**Answer: 2/11**

Justification: Of the 36 equally likely ordered outcomes, exactly 11 contain at least one 4 (the 6 with a 4 on the first die plus the 6 with a 4 on the second die, minus the double-counted (4,4)). Among those 11, the ones summing to 9 are (4,5) and (5,4), i.e. 2 outcomes. Hence the conditional probability is 2/11 ≈ 0.1818.

(Note the subtlety: this differs from the answer you'd get by conditioning on a *specific* die showing 4, which would be 1/6.)
Claude Sonnet 5frontier reference
2/11

There are 11 equally likely outcomes with at least one die showing a 4: (4,1),(4,2),(4,3),(4,4),(4,5),(4,6),(1,4),(2,4),(3,4),(5,4),(6,4). Of these, only (4,5) and (5,4) sum to 9. So the conditional probability is 2/11.
Claude Fable 5frontier reference
The probability is 2/11.

Of the 36 equally likely outcomes, 11 include at least one 4 (six with a 4 on the first die, six with a 4 on the second, minus the double-counted (4,4)). Among these, the sum is 9 only for (4,5) and (5,4), i.e. 2 outcomes. By the definition of conditional probability, P(sum = 9 | at least one 4) = (2/36)/(11/36) = 2/11.
Claude Haiku 4.5frontier reference
2/11

Given at least one die shows 4, there are 11 equally likely outcomes: (4,1), (4,2), (4,3), (4,4), (4,5), (4,6), (1,4), (2,4), (3,4), (5,4), (6,4). Of these, exactly two sum to 9: (4,5) and (5,4). Therefore, the probability is 2/11.
Reference
Gold — the correct answerreference
2/11 — die Bedingung (mindestens eine 4) hat 11 gleichwahrscheinliche Ausgänge; Summe 9 darunter: (4,5) und (5,4) → 2/11. Häufiger Fehler: 2/12 oder 1/6.
Results at a glance— every model in this round with score, response time and status.

Who wrote what

ModelBlind scoreLatencyStatus
qwen3.5:9b 10.024.4 sOK
gemma4:26b 10.0119.6 sOK
deepseek-r1:14b 10.020.0 sOK
qwen3:14b 10.016.3 sOK
qwen3-coder:30b 10.013.0 sOK
llama3.1:8b 3.043.6 sOK
qwen3:8b 10.015.0 sOK
mistral-small:24b 10.061.0 sOK
command-r:35b 1.090.6 sOK
qwq:32b 10.086.0 sOK
deepseek-r1:32b 3.043.5 sOK
Verdict

8 of 11 answering local models matched the gold answer (blind score ≥ 8): gemma4:26b, mistral-small:24b, qwen3-coder:30b, qwen3:14b, qwen3.5:9b, qwen3:8b, deepseek-r1:14b, qwq:32b.